I'm looking for a quick way to compare heroes' damage and healing rates. What should a per-second comparison include, and what can it miss?
How useful are damage and healing per second comparisons in Overwatch?
Answers
A compact table can be a useful starting point if it spells out the assumptions. One possible comparison is the damage or healing dealt during exactly one second, with every shot hitting and weapons at maximum charge where applicable.
Keep the exceptions visible. For example, a comparison that excludes headshots for most heroes but includes them for Widowmaker and Ana isn't a straight comparison of identical conditions. The same goes for heroes whose primary fire isn't the main way they contribute damage.
Reply to this answer
I wouldn't treat the ranking as a list of who does the most damage in a match. Perfect pellet hits at point blank are very different from what Reaper, Tracer, or Doomfist can reliably land in a fight.
Abilities matter too. A hero like Genji can have a low primary-fire number and still use other parts of the kit to finish a target. Illari's slower shots are another reason a single one-second figure doesn't tell the whole story.
Reply to this answer
For a practical reference, you could mark which damage figures exceed Tracer's health. That gives the table a quick threshold to compare against, though hitting it under ideal assumptions doesn't mean a hero will reliably get the elimination in a real fight.
Reply to this answer
Make sure the table says whether it's showing maximum output or something more typical. Maximum Zarya or Symmetra charge and Mauga firing both guns are useful benchmarks, but those conditions won't necessarily be present whenever a fight starts. Healing numbers need the same kind of context as damage numbers.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
P8throwTech~Later:
Worth noting that some weapons have unusual firing patterns, so a one-second window can make their numbers look odd.