How unlucky is 665 villager rerolls without Protection IV or Efficiency V?

November 18, 2026 3 answers
Asked by 16bitPigeonhole

I've rerolled librarian trades roughly 665 times without seeing either Protection IV or Efficiency V. Is that just bad luck, or could something be missing from the probability calculation? The game version is listed as 1.26.2 with Essential.

Answers

kartApexTally

The calculation depends on the chance per reroll, which isn't given here. If each roll is independent and the chance of either book is p, the chance of missing both across 665 rolls is (1 - p) raised to the 665th power.

For illustration, if the combined chance were 1%, the chance of no success would be about 0.13%. If it were 0.1%, the chance would be about 51%. Those are examples, not confirmed trade odds.

Reply to this answer
ROMbank_Quilt

Before plugging in a percentage, check the exact game edition and version, plus whether any trade rebalance settings or other changes to villager trades are active. The listed version and Essential alone don't establish the trade pool or the odds.

Also check whether the librarian can actually offer the two books you're counting at the trade level being rerolled. If either book is excluded under those settings, the chance of finding it there is zero.

Reply to this answer
lootProcLanyard

The attempt count is worth treating as an estimate, since it comes from axe durability rather than a direct count. That won't explain everything by itself, but an exact probability would be misleading without knowing how many eligible trades were actually checked.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions