In Mage: The Awakening 2e, a player wants their mage to be able to handle challenges with mundane abilities, without needing to cast spells beforehand. I worry that making those challenges easy enough without magic will make them trivial when someone does use it.
One example was an enchanted door that required an exceptional song and dance. The roll had a five-die penalty, and the player's four-die pool failed despite spending Willpower. How should we set expectations for challenges like that?
deckDrawstepDoodle:
The failed roll alone does not prove the difficulty was wrong. The useful question is whether the chance of failure matched what everyone understood about the challenge.