How does the Three Clue Rule help keep a mystery moving?

November 19, 2026 3 answers
Asked by speedrunSally

I'm planning a mystery scenario and want the investigation to stay solvable without just leading players from one scene to the next. How should I use the Three Clue Rule?

Answers

hitConfirm_5D

For each conclusion the players need to reach, prepare at least three ways to get there. They might miss one clue, misunderstand another, and still have a third to work with. The clues should be separate enough that missing one scene doesn't wipe out all three.

Say they need to find a warehouse. A shipping record, a witness who saw a delivery, and a distinctive packing label could all point there. They don't have to spell out the whole answer, but each should give the group something useful to pursue.

aggroBudget:

That also gives players choices about where to look, rather than making the warehouse depend on one specific conversation.

Reply to this answer
rogueProcAtCheckout

Think about what a clue lets the players do next. A name, location, or upcoming event can be a pointer to another place to investigate. A pile of interesting background information might be great atmosphere, but it won't help much when everyone is stuck asking where to go.

Look over each investigation scene and check whether it offers a lead the players can actually act on. That doesn't mean every lead has to point straight at the culprit.

Reply to this answer
ROMheader_6T

Don't put a required clue behind a single roll. If the group searches the right place or talks to the right person, give them the information they need to keep investigating. You can still use rolls for other consequences or details.

Some mystery games explicitly give out core clues to characters with the relevant abilities without requiring a roll. The useful distinction is between finding a lead and deciding what it means. The latter can still be tricky.

speedrunSally:

That helps. I was worried that giving out clues freely would make the mystery too easy.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions