My GM notes have clues and the answers behind the mystery, but those don't necessarily tell me what the party believes. How do you keep track of their theories without steering them toward the right answer?
How do you keep track of what players think is happening in a mystery?
Answers
Keep a separate little section for current beliefs. Write down the theory, what seems to have led them to it, and whether the whole party agrees or just one character. Update it when they change their minds.
The distinction matters. Knowing they saw a suspicious delivery is different from knowing they think it involved a kidnapping. That second note can make their next move much easier to understand.
Reply to this answer
Ask during the recap. Something like, what do you think is going on so far, and what are you planning to check next? Then listen without confirming or denying the theory. You don't need a formal interrogation every session.
shmupNeedleThread_6D:
That sounds easier than trying to catch every theory while I'm also running the session.
Reply to this answer
A wrong theory doesn't have to mean the mystery is broken. Let the players investigate it and discover what their evidence actually points to. If their suspicion was reasonable, the reveal can lead to a new decision rather than just a dead end.
I'd avoid quietly changing the answer just because their guess is interesting. Knowing what they believe helps you understand their choices, not necessarily rewrite the truth to match.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
deckManaBookmark+Clove:
Mark uncertain theories as uncertain, too. Players sometimes toss out a possibility without actually believing it.