What do you do when the players' theory fits the clues but is wrong?
My players have a coherent theory about a mystery, but the evidence they've found supports more than one explanation. They're about to act on the wrong one, and…
My players have a coherent theory about a mystery, but the evidence they've found supports more than one explanation. They're about to act on the wrong one, and…
My GM notes have clues and the answers behind the mystery, but those don't necessarily tell me what the party believes. How do you keep track of their…