In an investigative game, what do you do when players spend time questioning someone who knows nothing or searching a place unrelated to the case? I want their choices to matter, but I also don't want the session to stall while they chase a dead end.
How do you handle players looking for clues in the wrong places?
Answers
Let some searches come up empty, but make the result clear enough that the group can move on. An unrelated archive might simply contain nothing relevant. An empty house might have no calls to intercept.
You don't need to turn every detour into a clue. Just avoid making the players wonder whether they missed something because they searched badly. A clear dead end is a useful answer too.
Reply to this answer
I'd move a clue when it makes sense in the fiction, not just because the players looked somewhere. If a document could plausibly be filed in the archive they chose, sure, put it there. If the connection needs a string of coincidences to work, leave it alone.
You can also invent a new lead, but check what it implies before presenting it. A witness who suddenly knows about the crime may raise questions about how they learned it.
Reply to this answer
Before they sink a lot of time into it, tell them what their characters would reasonably know. If the house is visibly vacant and the phone is disconnected, say so before they set up a tap.
That's not the same as forbidding the plan. They can still follow it if they have a reason, but they get to make that choice with the information their characters have.
turnOrderByMug:
That sounds less restrictive than just telling them they're on the wrong track.
Reply to this answer
I'd be careful with aggressive questioning of an innocent person. They may know nothing about the case, but they can still react to being pressured. Let the interaction have consequences without making the person secretly relevant just to reward the interrogation.
Reply to this answer
Talk with the group about what kind of mystery they want. Some players enjoy testing theories and accepting that a wrong lead goes nowhere. Others would rather keep the investigation moving even if that means the GM adapts clues more freely.
There's room for both, but the table will have a rougher time if the players expect one style and the GM is running the other.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
whiffConfirm_3V:
That also helps distinguish a genuinely empty lead from one where the characters haven't found the right thing yet.