I want to run a campaign with an overarching threat and some plot twists, but I don't want the players to feel like they have to follow a predetermined story. How do you prepare for that?
How do I avoid railroading players in a planned campaign?
Answers
Prepare the threat, not the sequence of victories. Decide what the antagonist wants, what resources they have, and what they might do if nobody interferes. Then let the players choose how to interfere, and adjust the situation based on what happens.
You can still have a prophecy, rival factions, and big reveals. Just don't make the campaign depend on the party interpreting the prophecy one particular way or making a specific alliance. If they surprise you, let that become part of the story rather than steering them back to the planned scene.
Reply to this answer
Make sure choices have visible consequences. If the group flees an overwhelming army, that can change where the next session takes place. If they try to negotiate or look for allies instead, those should be real options too, even if success isn't guaranteed.
Having a dangerous army in the setting isn't railroading by itself. The problem is when every response except the one you planned gets shut down for no reason.
Reply to this answer
Talk about the campaign premise before you start. If you want a group of heroes who care about stopping a major threat, ask everyone to make characters who have a reason to get involved. That still leaves plenty of room for them to disagree about methods, allies, and what the prophecy means.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
bossPatternReader:
That helps. So the planned twists can be possibilities rather than things that absolutely have to happen?
co-opQueueSideways:
Exactly. You can know a rival's secret without deciding in advance whether the party discovers it, exploits it, or ignores that rival entirely.