Is there a game where you play villains who keep losing?

November 21, 2026 3 answers
Asked by QTEinputBuffer_8J

Are there tabletop games built around playing a group of low-stakes villains whose plans keep falling apart in funny ways? I'm especially curious whether any games have mechanics for that, rather than just leaving it up to the players.

Answers

kartTireChalk

The distinction you're looking for is a game that makes failure fun, not just one that lets you play villains. A useful rule would reward a spectacularly failed scheme with resources for the next attempt, so losing keeps the story moving instead of ending it.

I'd look for games with recurring characters and consequences that complicate the next plan rather than permanently take the crew out of play. That still leaves room for the occasional small win, which can make the next disaster even funnier.

QTEinputBuffer_8J:

Yeah, a reward for the next scheme sounds closer to what I had in mind than just playing villains badly.

Reply to this answer
shmupBurstVector_7A

You could also build the rhythm into a game that doesn't require it. Agree that each session starts with a new scheme, and that the fun is in watching it unravel rather than protecting it from failure.

Let the characters care about each other even when they bicker. That gives everyone something to root for when the actual plan goes wrong.

Reply to this answer
kartDraftNotebook

One thing to settle beforehand: do the villains have to lose every time, or do they just usually lose? If the outcome is guaranteed, the interesting part becomes how the plan collapses. If it isn't, the players can still try to win and let the dice create the mess.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions