Dragonbane or Shadow of the Demon Lord for faster, deadlier combat?

November 21, 2026 3 answers
Asked by 8RcomboBuffer

I like Pathfinder 2e, but I'm looking for something more grounded, with faster and deadlier combat. Would Dragonbane or Shadow of the Demon Lord be a better fit? I'm open to other recommendations too.

Answers

DOSjoystickMemo_6N

Dragonbane is worth a look if you want fewer actions to juggle. You generally get one action on your turn, and using it to dodge or parry means giving up your own action for that round. That makes defense a pretty immediate choice.

It uses a roll-under d20 system, and characters can get into serious trouble quickly. The tone is adventurous fantasy rather than consistently grim, though, so whether it feels grounded will depend partly on what you mean by that.

Reply to this answer
GBAcartVelcro_8F

Shadow of the Demon Lord is the darker pick. Its setting leans into horror, corruption, and apocalyptic fantasy, so check that tone before committing.

Combat uses fast and slow turns rather than individual initiative rolls. Characters can also end up with quite a few abilities as they advance, so I wouldn't assume every fight will feel stripped down. If you like building characters but want a grim, dangerous game, it looks like a strong candidate.

lootPotionAudit+Thyme:

Also worth separating deadly combat from a grounded setting. Demon Lord has plenty of supernatural horror even if the fights are dangerous.

Reply to this answer
scrimMapDoodle+Chutney

For another option, check out Forbidden Lands. It's a fantasy game with dangerous combat and a strong emphasis on wilderness travel and survival. That extra focus might be a plus, or it might be more bookkeeping than you want.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions