Tinker's win rate is around 46%, but his Aghanim's Shard still feels frustrating to play against. He can force out saves, return from the fountain, and finish people off. Does the shard need a change, or is the problem more about how the hero plays?
Does Tinker's shard feel too strong even with his low win rate?
Answers
A low win rate doesn't necessarily mean every part of a hero's kit feels fair. Tinker can lose plenty of games and still have a shard that makes individual fights miserable.
I'd look at changing the shard rather than just weakening the whole hero. Keeping his niche, demanding playstyle sounds more interesting than making him broadly ineffective.
Reply to this answer
The fountain reset sounds like a big part of the frustration too. If Tinker forces out your team's saves and comes back before you can recover, the shard may feel especially oppressive as part of that sequence. Changing it alone might not address the whole issue.
Reply to this answer
I'm not convinced the shard needs a nerf based on that alone. A 46% win rate doesn't settle the question either, but it does make me wary of treating an annoying interaction as proof that the hero is too strong overall.
It would help to separate how often the sequence wins fights from how bad it feels when it works.
Reply to this answer
There's also a build question here. Kaya, Blink, Aether Lens, the shard and Keen-Eyed are all mentioned as part of the setup, so it's hard to pin the result on the shard alone. The combination could be the thing worth examining.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
deckTech.Knapsack:
Yeah, it's the repeat engagement that gets me. Surviving the first time doesn't feel like enough.