Does San Andreas actually have deeper driving than GTA IV and V?

November 16, 2026 4 answers
Asked by manaByBicycle

San Andreas driving gets called arcade-like, but its cars can feel quite different from one another. Does that make it more mechanically interesting than the driving in GTA IV and V?

Answers

SaveSlotSundial

That's a reasonable case for San Andreas. Cars such as the Elegy, Comet and Infernus can feel distinct even though they're all quick cars. That gives you a reason to learn a particular vehicle rather than just pick the fastest one.

Throttle control matters too. How much power you apply, when you steer and when you countersteer can change how a slide develops. Arcade handling doesn't have to mean there's nothing to learn.

manaByBicycle:

So the variety between individual cars is as much a part of the appeal as drifting itself?

guildChatLurker:

Exactly. A slide is more interesting when different cars need different inputs to keep it going.

Reply to this answer
arcadeShift+Lark

I wouldn't treat arcade feel and mechanical depth as opposites, but I also wouldn't call IV and V shallow just because they reward different things. It depends whether you value controlling slides and car-to-car variety most, or prefer the way another game handles weight and steering.

Reply to this answer
parryByCanoe

Try the same stretch of road with a few cars before deciding. Pay attention to how they turn, how easily the rear steps out under power and what it takes to straighten them up. Then compare that with what you enjoy in IV and V. A favourite handling model doesn't have to be the most realistic one.

Reply to this answer
DPSonProbation

The keyboard point is worth separating from the physics. Even without an analog trigger, how and when you apply power can affect a slide. That doesn't mean digital input offers the same fine control as an analog trigger.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions