I've seen advice that danger dice need to greatly outnumber action dice to make a noticeable difference. But a challenge to the commonly cited calculations suggests equal pools may already bring success odds close to 70%. Which is right?
Do danger dice really need to outnumber action dice in Neon City Overdrive?
Answers
The equal-pool estimate is the one proposed by the challenge to the earlier calculation. If it holds up, using twice as many danger dice to target roughly 70% success could make rolls tougher than intended.
That doesn't mean equal pools always produce exactly 70%. The claim says the odds don't scale linearly, so the size of both pools matters too.
Reply to this answer
I'd be cautious about treating either number as settled without checking the actual calculation. Both claims depend on how the dice are rolled, compared and resolved, including how ties and different outcome categories are handled.
A useful check would calculate or simulate several specific pool combinations using the rules as written, then report the probabilities for each outcome. That would make it easier to spot whether the disagreement is about the math or about what counts as a success.
Reply to this answer
The practical takeaway is not to pile on danger dice just because you heard they barely matter. Pick pool sizes for the situation, and be ready to revisit that choice if the results make the game feel harsher than you want.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
DOScursor+Breadcrumb:
So equal pools are more of a starting point than a fixed difficulty setting?
stunRouteByStapler:
Right. The disputed calculation matters most when someone treats the doubled danger pool as a reliable shortcut to a particular success rate.