Echoes of Aincrad seems to have a hard time making its death-game premise feel tense. With only two explorable floors and a slow opening, did it miss what made the setting interesting, or is that an unfair expectation for a single-player RPG?
Did Echoes of Aincrad waste its premise?
Answers
The floor count feels like a missed opportunity, even without expecting all one hundred. A few smaller areas, with time skips between them, could have made the climb feel like a journey rather than a setting the story keeps talking about.
Reply to this answer
For me the bigger issue is pacing, not the number of maps. The opening takes a long time to establish much urgency, which is a strange fit for a story about being trapped in a death game.
There are later moments that come closer to that tension, but getting there can be a slog.
Reply to this answer
I wouldn't judge it against an imagined full-scale online game. Translating that premise into a single-player RPG is a tough design problem, and more floors alone wouldn't necessarily make it better. The question is whether the places and story it does have make the stakes feel real.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
comboTrial!NoNotes:
That's fair. I wasn't expecting every floor, just a stronger sense that the characters were making progress through the world.