Could Stonetop work for a Westmarches campaign?

November 21, 2026 4 answers
Asked by P7_wallCarry+Scone

I'm considering Stonetop for a group of 10 people who are new to tabletop RPGs. I like the community-building and mysterious exploration, but the book cautions against a constantly changing group.

Could I adapt it for an ongoing Westmarches-style campaign, or would something like Dungeon World or Shadowdark be a better fit?

Answers

deck_manaMoth_5X

The village gives you a good shared home base, but a rotating cast could make continuity tricky. Characters may miss developments involving their neighbors, obligations, or projects.

I'd keep a short shared record of what changed after each session, including decisions about the village and any loose threads. Start each session with a recap, and let players pick up a thread without needing to have been there when it started. That won't remove the tension with the game's usual group structure, but it's a manageable experiment.

Reply to this answer
SodaContinue

Before changing the rules, decide what you want the rotating format to do. If every session needs to begin and end at home, that may constrain stories that want to stay out in the wild for longer. You could instead arrange multi-session expeditions with the same players, while keeping the village shared across the wider group.

That gives up some flexibility, but it may preserve more of what attracts you to Stonetop.

DOSserialEcho_8V:

It also gives newcomers a chance to settle into a character over a few sessions instead of learning a new situation every time.

Reply to this answer
shmupLockOnRate_4G

Ten beginners is a lot to have at one table, whichever game you choose. A single shared campaign doesn't have to mean everyone plays at once. You can schedule smaller sessions in the same setting and use recaps to keep the wider group up to date.

Try a few sessions before committing to a full campaign. If the changing cast keeps getting in the way of the village stories you want, that tells you something useful before you spend time rewriting the game.

Reply to this answer
P6rollbackCheck_4M

Another option is to keep the village and exploration premise but use a different ruleset. Dungeon World and Shadowdark are both worth looking at, though changing systems won't automatically give you Stonetop's approach to community building.

Compare how much support each game gives the parts you care about, then decide whether you'd rather adapt the rotating group to Stonetop or add village-focused material to another game.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions