Could Keep Inventory and XP loss be separate settings?

November 20, 2026 4 answers
Asked by LANguestWithSnacks

I like keeping my items when I die in Minecraft, but I still want death to cost me some experience. Could those be separate gamerules instead?

Answers

ROMchecksumWaffle

That would make sense as two independent switches. You could keep items but lose XP, drop items but keep XP, keep both, or lose both. The existing no-loss setup could still be an option.

Reply to this answer
GBCtileLibrarian

Keeping gear while losing experience sounds like a good middle ground if recovering a whole inventory feels too punishing. Death would still have a cost, without making one mistake potentially wipe out all your equipment.

Reply to this answer
P2dashBrake_8J

The reverse setting could be useful too. Some players might be happy to retrieve dropped items but would rather not lose their accumulated experience. Separate controls would let both preferences work without changing how anyone else chooses to play.

Reply to this answer
P2meterBurn_8C

Separate rules sound cleaner than changing Keep Inventory alone. If the current rule stopped preserving XP, existing worlds using it for both would need some way to retain that behavior.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions