Could Daggerheart's duality dice work in other games?

November 19, 2026 4 answers
Asked by hitstopByLunchbox

I like how Daggerheart uses two dice to bring a bit of uncertainty beyond simple success or failure. Could that idea work in games outside heroic fantasy, especially ones that aren't focused on combat?

Are there earlier games with similar mechanics? And could a designer use the idea in a separate game without calling it Daggerheart compatible?

Answers

MUDquester_4V

Sure, but the dice need something meaningful to affect. You could roll two different-colored dice, use their total to determine success, and let the higher die suggest whether the outcome brings an opportunity or a complication.

For a mystery game, the complication might be unwanted attention rather than damage. In a relationship-focused game, an opportunity might open a new conversation. Decide what happens on ties and how often you want complications before building the rest of the rules around it.

GGs+Griddle:

Keeping success and complications separate also means a failed roll doesn't have to stop the story. The clue could still turn up, just with a new problem attached.

Reply to this answer
checkpointCollector

The useful comparison is with games that separate whether you succeed from how things get complicated. Powered by the Apocalypse games often have partial successes, though they don't use this same two-die reading. That's a design relative, not proof of where Daggerheart got the idea.

I wouldn't assume a direct borrowing without a designer statement or another reliable source. Similar mechanics can emerge independently.

Reply to this answer
oneContinueByLantern

On the legal side, there's a difference between using a game mechanic and copying someone's rulebook text, branding, or other protected material. Renaming things alone isn't a guarantee that a game is legally clear, and compatibility claims can raise separate questions.

Write your own rules and check the applicable license and trademark guidance if you plan to publish. For a commercial release, a lawyer familiar with games and the relevant jurisdiction is a better bet than a quick answer here.

Reply to this answer
manaCurveByWicket

Watch out for the math when transplanting it. The total of two dice clusters around the middle, unlike a single die, so existing target numbers may not carry over. The higher die can add a second dimension, but its results won't necessarily have the same effects as they do in Daggerheart.

Try a few sample difficulties and record successes, failures, opportunities, and complications. Then adjust the targets and consequences to match the tone you want.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions