Can I make a crunchy RPG lighter by borrowing another game's rules?

November 19, 2026 2 answers
Asked by quickplay_ish

I like the urban fantasy mystery premise and narrative tags in City of Mist, but the rules feel a bit heavy for my group. Could a lighter game provide the mechanics without losing what makes the setting appealing?

Answers

GBAcartridgeNerd

Neon City: Overdrive is worth a look. Its original focus is cyberpunk heists, but its tag-based character mechanics could fit urban fantasy mysteries too.

Try translating each City of Mist theme into a trademark, then sort the character's useful tags into edges and their complications into flaws. Use the lighter game's rules to resolve actions rather than trying to carry over every mechanic from City of Mist.

saveFile_5M:

That sounds like a useful starting point. I'd check each character's tags for overlap during conversion rather than assuming every tag needs a direct equivalent.

Reply to this answer
kartBrake!Turnstile

I'd start with one short mystery and see which parts of the original game you actually miss. Keep the setting and character concepts, use the simpler rules for everything else, and only add back a rule if its absence causes a problem at the table.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions