Energy rifles seem to give up damage and magazine options compared with ballistic weapons, especially in automatic configurations. Is that a fair comparison, and what would you change?
Do energy rifles need a buff compared with ballistic guns?
Answers
The automatic damage drop looks like the clearest place to start. In the listed base configurations, the ballistic rifles keep their displayed damage when switched to automatic, while lasers and plasma lose damage. I'd narrow that gap before making a broad buff to every energy weapon.
Damage per shot isn't the whole fight, though. Fire rate and reload time matter too, so I'd want those checked before deciding how big the adjustment should be.
Reply to this answer
Magazine choices could use some attention as well. The listed ballistic rifles have larger magazine options, while the energy guns have more limited capacities. More shots between reloads would make them feel better without necessarily pushing up their damage per hit.
Reply to this answer
I wouldn't treat laser and plasma as one balance problem. Plasma has split damage and can compare differently depending on the configuration, including its sniper and flamer setups. A blanket energy damage increase could help one setup more than another needs.
Reply to this answer
Ammo weight is part of the tradeoff too. Even if the damage gets closer, carrying heavier ammo can still make an energy build less convenient. Reducing that burden would be a useful quality of life change.
Reply to this answer
The perk-free comparison is a useful baseline, but it doesn't tell us everything about a finished build. Science perks can boost energy damage, so I'd compare realistic builds as well as the unmodified guns before deciding where parity should land.
P18!DashBudget:
That makes sense. I'm curious whether the extra investment needed to close the damage gap is part of the balance problem too.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
HPbarByKettle:
That also makes the displayed numbers tricky to compare directly. The split damage needs to be considered alongside the target's defenses.