I like what I've read of the Basic Roleplaying quickstart, especially the familiar dice, hit points, and potentially lethal combat. Can it still feel like D&D, or should I look at something closer to that style?
Can BRP give me a D&D-like game, or is there a closer fit?
Answers
BRP can certainly run fantasy adventures with dungeons, monsters, and treasure. The bigger change is how characters work: it's generally skill based rather than built around D&D-style classes and levels. Attacks and other skills usually use percentile rolls, even though other dice show up too.
If what you want is the adventure setup, BRP can do it. If the class abilities and level progression are a big part of the appeal, it may feel quite different at the table.
Reply to this answer
For familiar d20 rolls and dangerous fights, I'd look at an old-school D&D-style game first. Old School Essentials is one option. It keeps classes, levels, armor class, and d20 attacks closer to the D&D family than BRP does.
That doesn't make it a replacement for every version of D&D, though. Check its character options and spell rules against the edition you like.
Reply to this answer
RuneQuest is worth a look if the BRP side is what grabbed you. It's a fantasy game in the same broad percentile family, with more emphasis on skills and a setting of its own. It won't make the core rolls more like D&D, but it gives you a fantasy framework to compare with building from BRP.
Reply to this answer
I'd try the quickstart before adding a d20 just because it's familiar. The percentile roll is doing a different job from a D&D attack roll, and converting skills to a d20 can change how finely they're rated. A short fight and a few skill checks should tell you more than the dice alone.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
buttonMapTriage:
Good distinction. Using the same physical dice doesn't necessarily mean the character-building or combat will feel similar.