Are there RPGs where one stat sets the dice pool and another adds a bonus?

November 21, 2026 4 answers
Asked by P3okiRoute_8H

I'm working on a system where a stat determines how many dice you roll and a skill adds to the result. For example, Brains 5 and Deduction 3 would mean rolling five dice and adding 3.

Are there existing RPGs with a similar setup, and how do they handle the roll?

Answers

P8throwLoop_5Q

One detail will make a big difference when comparing systems: what happens to those five dice? You could add them all together, keep only the highest, or count dice that meet a target. The +3 means something quite different in each case.

For a useful comparison, look for both where the pool size comes from and where the skill bonus gets applied. A game that combines an attribute and skill into one pool is related, but it isn't quite the same mechanic.

Reply to this answer
quickroll!NotYet

If you add all the dice, increasing Brains changes both the average result and the range of possible results. Increasing Deduction just shifts the total upward. That gives the two stats different effects, which could be a nice reason to keep them separate.

It's worth checking how quickly the dice total grows compared with the skill bonus, though. With five dice, a flat +3 may matter a lot less than adding another die, depending on the die size and target numbers.

Reply to this answer
scrimMapPocket_4W

Keeping the highest die would give you a different feel. More dice make a good roll more likely, but the best die is still capped at its maximum value. The skill bonus then moves that result up, so training can let a character reach targets that extra dice alone can't.

Just decide whether the bonus applies to the single kept die or to the total of several kept dice. Those will have pretty different odds.

Reply to this answer
CRTcolorGate_2M

You could also count successes instead of adding the dice. In that case, spell out whether the skill adds three successes, changes the number each die needs to succeed, or modifies something else. Those aren't interchangeable, and a flat three successes could be huge in a small pool.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions