I'm looking for games where another playthrough changes more than the difficulty. For example, can you use what you carried over to change an early story event and send the plot in a different direction?
Are there games where New Game Plus actually changes the story?
Answers
Chrono Trigger is a good fit for the early boss idea. New Game Plus lets you challenge the final boss much earlier, and winning at different points can lead to different endings.
The main caveat is that you aren't getting a whole new campaign after beating that boss early. The changes are mostly in how and when the story ends.
Reply to this answer
NieR: Automata is worth a look if you want later playthroughs to add major story material. It doesn't work quite like a conventional New Game Plus where you rewrite the opening, though. Keep playing after the first ending, because the later routes reveal more and continue the story.
Reply to this answer
Undertale handles repeat runs differently. Choices from an earlier run can affect later dialogue and outcomes, so the game can feel like it remembers what happened. It's less about bringing powerful stats back to beat an early boss and more about the consequences of your choices.
Reply to this answer
If gameplay changes count too, Dark Souls II has extra enemies and other differences in New Game Plus. It doesn't substantially rewrite the story, but it gives you more to discover than just tougher versions of the same fights.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
Related Discussions