Are Italian subs actually balanced, or do they just look weak on paper?

November 4, 2026 4 answers
Asked by mossy_caster

Looking at the stats alone, these subs seem pretty low impact at first glance. They have a useful submarine surveillance range, but the rest looks a bit underwhelming. Slow ship speed, average to weak torps with a long reload, meh concealment, limited dive time, and no hydrophone.

They do have smoke, heal, and a speed or reload boost mechanic, so maybe that changes the picture. But from the outside, it still feels like a very passive ship that depends on setup more than pressure. Am I missing something obvious about how they are meant to work?

Answers

byteforge

The main thing people miss is that the ship is not really meant to play like a classic aggressive sub. It leans more into set piece attacks, repositioning, and forcing awkward reactions. The reload and speed boost tied to the special key is a big part of that, because it turns the boat from sluggish to much more threatening for short windows.

On paper the torps do look tame, but stealthy torps with a decent launch angle can still be annoying if the enemy is already busy. The smoke is also not just for hiding, it can buy time to line up a strike or mess with enemy spotting. So it is less about raw damage output and more about creating uncomfortable situations.

K1ckstart:

Yeah, that makes sense. It sounds more like a utility sub than a brawler sub.

Reply to this answer
lilt.run

I think the bigger balance lever is that the weaknesses stack up in a way that keeps it honest. Slow movement, limited dive time, and no hydrophone all make it easier to predict once you have a read on it. That means the player has to plan a lot more carefully than with a sub that can just keep chaining pressure.

The surveillance range is nice, but it does not fix the rest of the kit by itself. If the enemy team is alert, the sub still has to spend a lot of time trying to get into the right position. So balanced does not necessarily mean weak, just that the ship has a lot of friction built into it.

mossy_caster:

That matches the impression I got. It feels like a kit with a lot of built in inconvenience.

Reply to this answer
sidecarpilot

What makes them work is that the tools are weirdly good in combination. Smoke lets them break contact or set up a different angle, the heal helps them survive longer than you would expect, and the burst mode gives them the tempo swing they need to actually convert an opening.

The torps being slow is not automatically a problem if they are hard to see and the enemy has to move around while also dealing with the sub threat. That said, I do think they can feel gimmicky. They probably rely more on matchup and timing than a lot of other subs, which is why they may seem weak until someone plays them well.

Reply to this answer
THR0TTLE!

To me the balance question is less about damage numbers and more about how frustrating the ship is to interact with. Even if the raw output is modest, a sub that can vanish, smoke up, heal, and then spike its speed and reload can still be annoying in the hands of someone patient.

So I would not call them overpowered from the stat sheet, but I would not call them harmless either. They probably sit in that awkward middle spot where they are situationally effective and kind of niche, but still capable of punishing mistakes hard enough to matter.

patchyhands:

That is the part I was wondering about too, whether the annoyance factor is doing most of the work.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions