Any story games about teens dealing with supernatural stuff?

November 21, 2026 5 answers
Asked by 8XrankedRequeue

I'm looking for a story-driven game about teenagers or young adults dealing with something supernatural or unsettling. Friendship, relationships, and growing up matter as much to me as the mystery.

Answers

P4dashOption_6C

Life is Strange is probably the closest fit. It follows a teenage friendship alongside a mysterious power, with choices and conversations doing a lot of the work. The supernatural mystery gets pretty dark, but there's plenty of everyday school and relationship drama too.

Reply to this answer
LANguestCasually

Oxenfree has a group of teens, an eerie island, and a lot of conversational back and forth. It's shorter and more focused on dialogue than puzzles or combat, so it's a good pick if you want the group dynamic front and center.

Reply to this answer
shmupLaserLinter

Persona 4 Golden has a strong ensemble of high school friends investigating a mystery with supernatural elements. There's a lot more game around the story, though: dungeon crawling, turn-based battles, and managing your time between school and relationships.

Persona 5 Royal is another option if you like that structure, though its teen cast and supernatural adventures have a different tone.

mechLoadoutTidy:

Good distinction on the gameplay. These are much longer and more combat-heavy than something like Oxenfree.

Reply to this answer
coinopPrizeCrank

Night in the Woods is worth a look if unsettling small-town mystery sounds good, even though its main character is a young adult rather than a teenager. It's very much about old friendships, feeling stuck, and figuring out what comes next.

Reply to this answer
CRTflickerFan

For a scarier take, try Until Dawn or The Quarry. Both put a group of young people in a horror story where your choices affect who survives. They're more focused on tense decisions and danger than on the everyday side of growing up.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions