Any PbtA or FitD-style games with more granular progression?

November 21, 2026 4 answers
Asked by lootSlotVelcro

I'm looking for a game with a PbtA or FitD feel, but more detailed progression. A wider range of ratings or more factors like gear affecting success would be great.

Player-facing rolls, mixed results, and support for an improvisational GM style are also appealing. Any recommendations?

Answers

DOSfontCacheMishap

Ironsworn is worth a look, especially if you want player-facing rolls and mixed outcomes. It uses an action die plus a stat against two challenge dice, with strong hits, weak hits, and misses.

Progression comes through buying assets, which add abilities and options, rather than a huge range of stat values. So it fits the broader definition of granular advancement better than the bigger numbers part.

Reply to this answer
lootQuickslotMuffin

Have a look at City of Mist if you want more things on the character sheet contributing to a roll. You invoke relevant tags to build your roll's power, and those tags can cover abilities, equipment, relationships, and other details.

It's still built around mixed results rather than a fine-grained success percentage. Advancement changes your themes and tags, so the detail is more about what applies in a situation than steadily climbing a long numerical scale.

Reply to this answer
coinopButtonLint_2P

For a FitD option, maybe Band of Blades. It adds a military campaign structure, specialist roles, equipment, and resource management around the core dice-pool approach. That gives you more moving parts, though the action ratings themselves are still fairly compact.

The campaign framework also gives the GM a lot to work with, but it may feel more structured than the freewheeling improvisation you're after.

Reply to this answer
GBCtileQueue_9R

It might help to separate two things here. More advancement choices aren't necessarily the same as more granular odds. A game can have lots of abilities and gear while still only shifting a roll by one or two dice.

If the wider numerical range is the main attraction, check the actual roll and advancement rules before committing. If you mostly want characters to acquire more distinct capabilities over time, asset or tag-based games may scratch that itch without larger ratings.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions