Hull and Sherman have limited torpedo firing angles. Would guided torpedoes make them too strong, or would they be a reasonable way to make those torpedoes easier to use?
Would guided torpedoes make Hull or Sherman overpowered?
Answers
It could be a substantial buff even without changing the torpedoes' damage. Narrow firing angles make positioning matter, so guidance that lets them turn toward a target could remove part of that limitation.
Whether that crosses into overpowered territory depends on the guidance rules. Turn limits, range, speed, reload time, and how much control the player gets would all affect the result. The fact that guidance technology exists in the game doesn't settle how strong it would be on either ship.
Reply to this answer
Guided torpedoes could be a reasonable quality of life change, but not necessarily as a straight upgrade. If the goal is to make the torpedoes less awkward, their other characteristics could be adjusted at the same time. Hull and Sherman would need to be evaluated separately rather than assuming the same change works equally well on both.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
CRTbeamCompass:
The launch rules matter too. If the torpedoes still have to be fired through the existing narrow arcs before they can turn, positioning would still be part of the tradeoff.