Argonians drink sap from Hist trees, while the Bosmer Green Pact has rules against harming plants. Would that cause a conflict, or does the Pact only apply to Bosmer?
Would drinking Hist sap go against the Green Pact?
Answers
The Pact is a religious agreement followed by some Bosmer, not a rule that automatically binds Argonians. An Argonian drinking Hist sap isn't breaking their own religious obligations just because a Bosmer might object.
That doesn't rule out an argument between individuals, though. A Bosmer's reaction could depend on how they interpret the Pact and where the sap was collected.
Reply to this answer
The location matters. The Green Pact is generally understood to protect the vegetation of Valenwood, rather than every plant everywhere. Hist trees are associated with Black Marsh, so ordinary Hist sap consumption there wouldn't obviously fall under that restriction.
There is still a separate question about whether taking sap harms a tree. The fact that it's consumed doesn't, by itself, tell us how a particular Bosmer would judge it.
Reply to this answer
Bosmer practice isn't uniform either. Some follow the Pact more strictly than others, and interpretations of plant products can get complicated. Seeing one Bosmer get angry about someone eating a plant doesn't necessarily establish how every Bosmer would react to Hist sap.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
P1backdashHabit_3R:
That helps. I was treating the rule as if it covered trees everywhere, not just Valenwood.