Dota 2 could have an achievement system as another way to track progress. What kinds of achievements would be fun, and what problems might they cause?
Would achievements be a good addition to Dota 2?
Answers
I'd go for achievements that reward learning different parts of the game. Trying different roles, using items effectively, or completing a set of tutorial challenges could give newer players something to work toward without tying everything to rank.
Reply to this answer
The tricky part is making sure achievements don't encourage people to sabotage matches. A reward for getting a certain number of kills with a specific ability might tempt someone to chase the achievement instead of helping their team.
Objectives tied to normal team play would be safer, though the exact requirements would still need care. Some challenges might work better outside regular competitive matches.
Reply to this answer
Cosmetic badges or a profile display would be enough for me. No gameplay rewards, no pressure to finish every challenge. Just a few optional milestones to look back on.
Reply to this answer
I'd rather see unusual, specific challenges than a long list of grindy counters. Something that recognizes a clever interaction would be more interesting than playing hundreds of matches just to fill a progress bar.
That said, rare achievements should be designed so players aren't waiting around for an unlikely situation at the expense of the match.
scrimTape_3K:
That sounds more appealing than making the whole system about match totals.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
GBAtrace~Unindexed:
Hidden achievements could also be a fun surprise, though keeping the requirements secret wouldn't necessarily stop people from trying to force them once they're known.