What if each season had a tree that let players customize its main mechanic? Could that add replay value, and would a separate tree for the open world be worthwhile too?
Would a skill tree for each seasonal mechanic make seasons more replayable?
Answers
It could work if the choices actually change how the mechanic plays, rather than just adding small damage bonuses. Different branches could encourage different ways of tackling the same seasonal content, giving players a reason to try another setup.
The tricky part is making those choices meaningful without making one branch feel mandatory. Letting players change their selections would help them experiment without feeling locked into an early guess.
Reply to this answer
A new tree every season sounds fun, but it also risks becoming another progression screen to fill out before the interesting part starts. The mechanic itself should be enjoyable first. A tree could add variety, but it shouldn't be needed to make the basic version feel complete.
Reply to this answer
The open world tree is the part I'd be most interested in. A longer-term set of choices could give players a way to shape that content beyond a single season. It would need a clear purpose, though, so it doesn't just duplicate whatever the seasonal tree is doing.
Reply to this answer
There's room to make iconic mythic items more interesting too. Effects like a chance to cast a skill twice or a larger skill area could give an item a distinct identity, especially if they bring back ideas from removed tempering options.
That's a separate design problem from seasonal trees, though. Those effects would need to fit the item and avoid making other gear feel pointless.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
GG_noMic:
That also raises the question of how much progress should carry over. Starting fresh can be fun, but repeating a long unlock process might get old.