Riot says it is focusing on Maokai jungle because of concerns about his top lane experience. Is that a fair reason to leave his top lane weak, especially when champions like Gragas can also be hard to interact with?
Why is Maokai getting jungle attention instead of top?
Answers
The jungle focus makes sense if the goal is to preserve his identity as a tank who controls space. Saplings and his other tools can matter around jungle paths and objectives without making every top lane trade revolve around whether he can disengage.
That does not necessarily mean top is permanently abandoned. It does mean a general buff could be tricky if Riot wants to improve one role without making the other too strong.
Reply to this answer
Top deserves a look too. Maokai has been played there for years, and if changes to items and the wider meta have left him struggling, jungle buffs do not really address that. Riot could look at the reasons his laning feels bad instead of treating the role as a lost cause.
Reply to this answer
The concern with top Maokai is not just that he is defensive. He can play back, farm safely and use W and Q to get out of trades, which can make the lane frustrating for the other player. Buffing his numbers might make him better without making that matchup any more enjoyable.
P4chargeCheck+Paprika:
That still raises a fair comparison with Gragas. If both can disengage effectively, it would be useful to know why one is acceptable and the other isn't.
Reply to this answer
The Gragas comparison is worth asking about, but it does not prove the two should get the same treatment. They have different kits and may create different problems across a whole game. Riot would need to explain the distinction more clearly for the comparison to feel convincing.
Reply to this answer
His reported top lane numbers look rough, but a low pick rate and one set of stats do not tell the whole story. Matchups, mana pressure and how well he contributes after lane are also part of the question. The better debate is what changes would make top Maokai satisfying without bringing back a lane opponents hate.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
kartLaunchWindow:
That makes sense for a jungle buff. I still wonder whether top needs separate changes rather than just being left alone.