I'm new to Savage Worlds Adventure Edition and trying to understand the dice odds. It looks like a d4 skill die is slightly more likely than a d6 to hit a target of 6 because of acing. Does the Wild Die change that, and is it worth considering when building a character?
Why is a d4 sometimes better than a d6 in SWADE?
Answers
That oddity is real. A d4 hits 6 if it rolls a 4, then at least a 2 on the extra roll. That's 3 in 16, or 18.75%. A d6 hits 6 whenever its first roll is a 6, or about 16.67%.
With a Wild Die, you roll it alongside the skill die and keep the higher result after resolving any aces. For a Wild Card, the chance of hitting 6 is about 32.29% with a d4 skill and 30.56% with a d6 skill. The Wild Die narrows the gap but doesn't remove it.
Reply to this answer
I wouldn't build around target 6 alone. At the standard target of 4, a Wild Card succeeds about 62.5% of the time with a d4 skill and 75% with a d6 skill. Higher dice also change your chances at other totals and raises, so the useful comparison depends on what you're rolling for.
Modifiers matter too. A penalty effectively makes the required raw roll higher, so target 6 could come up when trying to hit 4 with a minus 2 modifier.
Reply to this answer
One distinction for your calculations: the Wild Die is for Wild Cards making trait rolls, not every character making every roll. Also, acing applies to each die separately before you compare them. You don't add the skill die and Wild Die together.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
airdashAtNoon:
So the smaller die gets more chances to ace, but that only helps at certain targets?
DpadMiscalculator:
Right. Aces make the distributions a little lumpy, rather than giving each die a smooth advantage at every possible target.