Why does playing tank feel like getting countered all the time?

November 18, 2026 4 answers
Asked by DpadWeatherproof

Some tanks seem to run into bad matchups even when the other team hasn't deliberately switched to counter them. Is this just how the role works, or are there too many heroes that can shut individual tanks down?

Answers

raidHealerish

There are a few different problems that can all feel like a counter. Reinhardt can struggle to reach flying heroes, lose his shield quickly to concentrated damage, or have a charge interrupted. Those are different interactions, even if they all make it harder to take space.

That doesn't necessarily make every hero with one of those tools a hard counter. The map, positioning, cooldowns and what both teams are doing can change how much a matchup matters. Still, facing several of those problems at once can feel rough.

deckCurveBySieve:

Yeah, an interruption matters a lot more if the other team is ready to punish it. It isn't always the same level of threat.

Reply to this answer
whiffPunishKettle

The accidental part makes sense to me. If a tank is vulnerable to several common tools, the enemy doesn't need to pick specifically against that tank for the matchup to feel bad. That can make it hard to tell the difference between a deliberate counterpick and a normal team composition.

Reply to this answer
buttonmasherish

Some matchups are also team problems rather than something the tank can solve alone. A highly mobile or flying hero can stay out of Reinhardt's reach or attack from another angle. Chasing them isn't always practical, so he may need his team to deal with that threat while he focuses elsewhere.

DpadWeatherproof:

That makes sense. It can still feel pretty limiting when the tank has to rely on the team for an answer, though.

Reply to this answer
14bitBrawler

Cooldown management and positioning can soften a bad matchup, but they don't necessarily erase it. If the other team has enough damage to pressure both the shield and Reinhardt himself, advancing can take a lot more work. That's a legitimate balance concern even when there is some room to play around it.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions