From a game design perspective, what does current health damage do for Blade of the Ruined King that a balanced percentage of max health damage would not? Armor still reduces the physical damage, so why choose one over the other?
Why does Blade of the Ruined King use current health damage instead of max health?
Answers
Current health damage is strongest at the start of a fight and falls off as the target loses health. Max health damage would stay the same on every hit, so it would contribute more consistently to finishing a target.
That gives the item a different damage pattern, not just a different power level. A lower max health percentage could be balanced, but it would feel different to use and to play against.
Reply to this answer
Armor does reduce the physical damage either way, but that doesn't make the distinction disappear. Max health damage keeps scaling with the target's full health pool even when they're nearly dead. Current health damage shrinks as that pool is depleted.
So changing the percentage is a tuning question, while choosing current or max health is also a question of what role the effect plays. Neither version has to be inherently impossible to balance.
Reply to this answer
The comparison with Liandry's Torment needs more than a tick count. You'd have to account for how often attacks land, the relevant damage rates, resistances, and how long the target stays in the fight. A per-hit effect and damage over time can have very different windows of effectiveness.
manaTinker-Offline:
And with current health damage, the target's health is changing between hits, so multiplying the first hit by the number of attacks would overstate the result.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
P2+JoystickJuggler:
So even if the total damage over a fight were similar, when the damage happens would still matter?
QTEbuffer+Luggage:
Exactly. Front-loaded damage helps get a healthy target low, while steady damage keeps more of its value near the end of the fight.