Why do the same carries keep coming back in competitive Dota?

November 20, 2026 4 answers
Asked by raidTauntOnCredit

It feels like heroes such as Shadow Fiend, Terrorblade and Templar Assassin keep returning to the competitive carry pool, while Anti-Mage and Phantom Assassin rarely seem to stick around. Is that mainly down to balance changes, or is there something about their kits that makes them harder to draft?

Answers

mechThrusterCoupon_8C

Kit design is a big part of it. A carry that can farm quickly and still contribute in several kinds of fights gives a team more options than one that needs a very specific matchup or a long, uninterrupted buildup.

That doesn't mean Anti-Mage can never work. A hero can be a good answer to a particular draft without being a reliable pick every game. Competitive teams also have to consider whether opponents can punish that pick once they see it coming.

Reply to this answer
GBCtilemapTinker

I wouldn't treat the carry pool as completely fixed. Heroes can drop out after nerfs and come back when the patch suits them again. The frustration is that familiar picks seem to have more paths back into the meta, while a hero like Phantom Assassin can disappear quickly after a strong period.

Reply to this answer
staminaBar~Halfish

Competitive balance and ordinary matchmaking can pull in different directions. A hero that depends on opponents giving it space might struggle against coordinated teams, but still be miserable to face in less coordinated games if its numbers get pushed too far.

That doesn't settle what should happen to Anti-Mage or Phantom Assassin. A rework could make one of them more useful in coordinated play without simply making it hit harder, but it would also change what people like about playing the hero.

GBCpaletteMender+Thyme:

And being annoying to play against isn't unique to carries. The same question applies to strong lane heroes that clear waves without much interaction.

Reply to this answer
deckTrinketByFeel

I'd also separate a hero being favored by the developers from a hero benefiting from its design. Some kits have damage, farming and utility baked in, so a numerical nerf may not remove all the reasons to pick them. That can look like favoritism, but the recurring picks alone don't establish intent.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions