Some newer biomes seem to appear within areas that would otherwise be an older biome, like Pale Gardens in Dark Forests and Cherry Groves where Meadows might generate. Why aren't they added as separate, larger regions?
Why do new Minecraft biomes replace parts of older ones?
Answers
World generation has to choose something for each area. Adding a biome means some land that could previously have generated as another biome will generate differently, even if the new one isn't technically a sub-biome.
Placing a new biome in an existing climate or terrain category can also make it fit the surrounding landscape. A grove on mountain slopes, for example, doesn't need its own enormous climate zone to show up.
Reply to this answer
Size is a design choice as much as a technical one. A small biome can feel like a distinct spot to discover without making a long stretch of the world look the same. A larger version would give players more room to build or gather resources there, but would also make other nearby terrain less common.
Reply to this answer
I'd be careful with the word sub-biome here. Two biomes can share terrain conditions or appear next to each other without one necessarily being defined as part of the other. Seeing a Pale Garden in a Dark Forest region tells you something about where it tends to appear, not by itself why the developers chose that setup.
Reply to this answer
There's a practical downside, though. If a biome only shows up under fairly specific conditions and its patches are small, finding a big enough area for a project can be frustrating. Separate generation rules or larger patches could make it easier to find, even if that meant less space for older biomes.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
laggingLad:
So being separate in the biome system wouldn't necessarily mean it gets extra land without taking space from anything else?
strafingByTeacup_4H:
Right. The map still has finite space, so changing the generation rules changes which biomes appear where.