I keep hearing that Impact, Puncture, and Slash mods are rarely worth a slot outside specific builds. What makes their scaling so different from other damage mods?
Why do IPS mods feel so weak in Warframe?
Answers
The big catch is that a physical damage mod boosts its own damage type, not the weapon's whole damage. If a weapon has 100 total damage but only 10 of that is Slash, a 120% Slash mod adds 12 damage, not 120.
Compare that with an elemental mod, which generally calculates its added damage from the weapon's total base damage. On a mixed-damage weapon, the elemental mod can add much more for the same slot.
Reply to this answer
There's also a difference between adding damage and changing which status effects you get. More Slash damage can make Slash procs more likely relative to the other damage types on the weapon. That can be useful on a status build, even if the raw damage increase isn't impressive.
But it won't raise the weapon's status chance by itself. And if the build already has a reliable way to cause Slash procs, that slot might be better spent elsewhere.
Reply to this answer
The opportunity cost is rough. A slot used for a physical damage mod could instead go toward crit, multishot, status, fire rate, or an element, depending on the weapon and build. Those options can improve more than one part of the weapon's output.
That doesn't make every IPS mod useless. A weapon heavily weighted toward one physical type, or a setup with a specific interaction like Coda Motovore or Melee Doughty, can make the calculation look different. Check the whole build rather than the mod's percentage in isolation.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
XPstash_AlmostGone:
So a weapon with almost all Slash would get more out of a Slash mod than one with just a little?
P1crossup~Unplanned:
Exactly. The starting damage distribution matters a lot, though you'd still want to compare the mod against other ways to use that slot.