Events like Dark Carnival and Crownfall are fun, but rewards like a single pie or a firework feel pretty useless. What makes filler rewards worth including, and what could replace them?
Why do event rewards include pies and fireworks?
Answers
Small novelty items can make an event feel festive without making every reward a major unlock. They are probably meant as little extras, not the main reason to play.
The problem is presentation. Getting one pie can feel disappointing if it takes the place of a reward you actually wanted. Keep the silly stuff as a bonus alongside more substantial rewards and it might land better.
Reply to this answer
I would rather have a choice. If someone likes fireworks, let them pick those. Otherwise, offer some kind of event currency or progress toward another reward.
Even a small amount would feel more useful than an item a player has no interest in using. The tradeoff is that the options would need to feel reasonably comparable.
Reply to this answer
Not every reward needs long term value. A silly effect can be fun precisely because it is disposable. But if the event hands them out so often that opening a reward becomes predictable, the joke wears thin.
Reply to this answer
It also depends on what the reward asks of you. A throwaway item for a quick activity is fine. If it follows a long or difficult objective, players are going to expect something more memorable.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
P4antiAir!Nearly:
Yeah, I don't mind them as a novelty. Getting another single-use item just doesn't feel much like a prize.