I thought mages were originally better at clearing waves while AD champions were better at taking turrets. When did AP start affecting turret damage, and why does that matter for build balance and objective pressure?
Why did AP scaling on turrets become a balance issue?
Answers
There are two changes to separate here. AP scaling on turret attacks already existed before the change that made the relevant damage magic. Changing the damage type wasn't the same thing as introducing AP scaling in the first place.
The supplied discussion doesn't establish exactly when either change happened or why it was made, so I wouldn't pin it on one champion without more evidence.
Reply to this answer
The design tension is role overlap. If a mage can clear a wave quickly and then threaten a turret without building AD, the defending team has to respect both the wave clear and the push. That can make the old division between clearing waves and damaging structures less distinct.
Whether a particular mage takes turrets as effectively as an AD carry depends on more than having AP scaling, though. Attack speed, stats, abilities and the opportunity to keep attacking all matter.
Reply to this answer
On the other hand, removing that scaling would come with its own tradeoff. AP builds could clear minions but get less out of the opening they create, while hybrid builds would need careful tuning so they aren't mediocre at both jobs. The question isn't just whether mages should damage turrets. It's how much pressure different builds should be able to apply.
Reply to this answer
The idea that a popular AD assassin forced the change is a theory, not an established explanation here. AD wave clear wasn't unique to one champion, so that example alone doesn't tell us what motivated the design decision.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
HPbyLunchbox:
That clears up my confusion. I was thinking of the switch to magic damage, not the original introduction of AP scaling.