Is there a stated design or balance reason for the restriction? Some offensive uniques are eligible and others aren't, and the number of options also seems to vary by class. More choices could open up some interesting builds.
Why can only some unique items become charms?
Answers
The available examples don't establish an official reason, so I wouldn't assume there's a confirmed balance rule behind the selection. It could be a design choice, but that's speculation without an explanation from the developers.
Reply to this answer
It doesn't look as simple as offensive versus defensive. Azurewrath can become a charm, while Raiment of the Infinite, Esadora's and Galvanic Azurite can't. That makes an item-by-item eligibility rule seem more useful than guessing from what an item does.
Reply to this answer
I can understand keeping mythics out, but regular uniques feel like a missed build-crafting opportunity. More charm options could make it possible to try combinations that aren't available now, even if some effects would need restrictions for balance.
Reply to this answer
The class difference is worth looking at separately from the offensive item question. One player reports fewer options for a sorcerer than a warlock, but that alone doesn't establish the full counts or whether the gap is intentional.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
hotbarTriage:
That also leaves the question of why those particular items were chosen. Eligibility tells us what works, not necessarily why.