A greater affix on a skill seems like it should be an upgrade, but rounding after masterworking can leave it with the same final skill bonus as a non-GA version. Is that how the scaling is supposed to work?
Why can a masterworked GA skill roll end up the same as a non-GA roll?
Answers
The frustrating part is that skill ranks are displayed as whole numbers. If the masterworking increase doesn't push the GA roll up to the next rank, the extra value can disappear in the final displayed result. That makes the greater affix feel wasted when both items end up showing the same bonus.
The example raises a question about whether the rounding is intended, but it doesn't establish why the system was designed that way.
Reply to this answer
I'd compare the final skill ranks before treating the GA as an upgrade. If both pieces land on the same number, the other affixes may matter more for that particular comparison.
Reply to this answer
This sounds like a scaling issue worth changing, even if the math is working as implemented. A GA skill affix could feel more rewarding if the final rounding or masterworking thresholds preserved a visible advantage over a comparable non-GA roll.
That wouldn't have to mean every upgrade adds a rank, but the fully upgraded result should give players a reason to care about the better starting affix.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
iFrame9!Tuner:
And that's the disappointing bit for a high-end drop. A rarer skill roll doesn't necessarily give you another rank after all that upgrading.