Some Dota 2 players at lower MMR report gaining around 40 for a win but losing around 25 for a loss, even with full rank confidence. Is this a calibration change or a bug, and how far up the ranks does it apply?
Why are lower-rank wins giving more MMR than losses take away?
Answers
There isn't enough here to tell whether it's intended or a bug. There are reports across lower brackets, but they don't establish that everyone below a particular rating gets the same adjustment. Full rank confidence also doesn't explain the cause by itself.
For now, treat the 4k cutoff as a question, not a confirmed rule. A clear explanation from the game developers would be needed to settle what is happening and where it applies.
Reply to this answer
The math does make climbing possible with a losing record if those numbers stay consistent. At 40 gained and 25 lost, you break even at a little over 38% wins. For example, 45 wins and 55 losses would still add 425 MMR.
That doesn't mean every account will get those exact changes, or that the rates will stay the same as rating rises. It just explains why the reported gains can happen without a positive win rate.
Reply to this answer
I'd track the actual changes for a while before drawing a line at any rank. Note the starting MMR, win or loss, points changed and rank confidence for each game. That would make it easier to see whether the pattern changes as the account climbs.
Reply to this answer
There are different ways to look at this. More generous gains could make progression feel less punishing, but if they persist over a wide range, a rising number might not mean the player is winning more often. Without knowing the intended design, it's hard to judge the effect on the ranking system as a whole.
Reply to this answer
The report of unusually high net worth in a separate ranked game doesn't establish a connection to MMR gains. Even if that match involved a gameplay bug, it would need its own investigation rather than being treated as an explanation for the rating pattern.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
buttonMap!Crooked:
That's also why the size of the adjustment matters. A small difference between wins and losses would have a much smaller effect over the same number of games.