Which tabletop RPGs would you offer a high school club?

November 19, 2026 4 answers
Asked by DOSfont~Crooked

Our club has mostly beginners, and some members seem more interested in stories or silly adventures than learning lots of rules. Fantasy is popular, but people also want to try sci-fi and other ideas.

I’m considering D&D, Maze Rats or Cairn, and Freeform Universal. What three to five games would give members useful choices without overwhelming them?

Answers

PUGreserve_5X

I’d start with D&D, Cairn, Freeform Universal, and one sci-fi game such as Lasers & Feelings. That gives people a familiar option, a lighter fantasy game, a flexible storytelling system, and a quick way to try a different genre.

Present them by what playing them feels like, not just by rules complexity. A short sample session for each would tell the club more than a stack of rulebooks. There’s no need to fill all five slots if four already give people enough variety.

CRTphosphor+Doormat:

Short sessions also make it easier for someone new to try a game without committing to a long campaign.

Reply to this answer
critWindow!Unspent

Keep D&D on the menu, but don’t assume everyone who recognizes it wants the same sort of game. One group might enjoy character abilities and tactical fights, while another just wants to make up a ridiculous fantasy story.

Ask what people want to do at the table first, then match a game to that. You could even run two different fantasy games rather than chasing maximum genre coverage.

Reply to this answer
coinopRetry!Again

For a silly option, take a look at Honey Heist. It has a simple premise about bears attempting a heist, so it’s easy to pitch as a one-session change of pace. It won’t replace a longer fantasy campaign, but it gives the club something quite different to try.

Reply to this answer
GBAboot_4P

I’d pay attention to who is willing to run each game. A great selection on paper won’t help much if nobody has time to learn it or prepare sessions. Pick a few manageable options, let interested members try running them, and revisit the choices after the club has played.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions