Some older ships seem to have newer alternatives that do much the same job better. Which ones feel like they have lost their identity, and what could bring them back without making them overpowered?
Which older ships have lost their niche to newer ones?
Answers
Republique comes to mind. Its accuracy and speed boost feel less distinctive when newer battleships also have strong gun handling or bigger speed boosts. The armor doesn't give it much room for mistakes either.
I'd rather see a targeted improvement to its main guns than another jump in battleship speed. Better armor penetration could give it a clearer role punishing broadside battleships, though the numbers would need care.
Reply to this answer
Schlieffen is a good example of a niche getting crowded. It used to stand out as a secondary battleship, but newer ships compete hard for that job. Its torpedoes still help distinguish it, although they're slow and their launchers can be knocked out.
I'd look at making the torpedo launchers more reliable before piling on more secondary damage. The limited heal and damage control charges already make a bad push costly.
Reply to this answer
Weak and obsolete aren't quite the same thing. Kitakami may be a poor ship overall, but its unusual torpedo playstyle gives it a reason to exist. For an older ship with no such hook, a small change that makes its preferred role more distinct could be better than a broad buff.
parryRoute_3M:
That's the distinction I was thinking of. A ship can be awkward and still offer something worth playing it for.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
mechActuator_7M:
That sounds more interesting than just making it faster. It would give the guns a reason to stand out again.