Which Mage edition fits a political modern magic campaign?

November 21, 2026 3 answers
Asked by rogueSkillReroute_3K

I want to run a modern game about mages dealing with rival factions and political maneuvering. I also want magic to have meaningful costs, starting characters to take risks for big effects, and combat to feel dangerous.

Should I start with Mage Revised, M20, or Unknown Armies? Other suggestions are welcome too.

Answers

P8blockPunish_2J

I'd start by comparing Mage Revised and M20 if the faction politics are the main attraction. Both are versions of Mage: The Ascension, so you're looking at different presentations of the same broad game rather than completely separate settings.

Skim their core books for the factions and the magic rules, then see which presentation makes you want to build a campaign. For your other goals, check how each handles magical backlash and combat before settling on one. A political setup alone won't guarantee that magic feels costly at the table.

Reply to this answer
GBCspriteBudget_4X

Unknown Armies is worth a look if you want modern magic to feel dangerous and strange, rather than assuming Mage is the only route. Read its character and magic sections alongside the Mage books and see whether the kinds of costs and conflicts they suggest fit your idea.

The key question is what kind of politics you want. A campaign about maneuvering between organized magical factions may need different setting support from one focused on conflicts between particular characters and their obsessions.

rogueSkillReroute_3K:

That's a useful distinction. I'm more interested in organized factions, but character-level conflicts could still be part of it.

Reply to this answer
kartFeatherBrake_8C

Before choosing, make a small test character in each game and try to work out a risky spell and a fight. That should tell you more about the feel you want than just reading the setting overview.

Pay attention to two separate things: what a starting character can attempt, and what happens when an attempt goes badly. Dangerous combat and costly magic aren't necessarily the same rule, and you might like how one game handles one but not the other.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions