Is there a useful way to compare how much better champion specialists perform than average players? I'm interested in mastery payoff, not just which champions are mechanically hardest.
Which champions reward mastery the most?
Answers
One way to measure it is to compare the win rate of the best players on a champion with the normal win rate for that same champion. If those are 57% and 49%, the gap is 8 percentage points.
A ranking based on that gap gives you a different answer from a tier list. A champion can have a big specialist advantage without being the strongest overall pick.
Reply to this answer
Watch the sample sizes before treating the top of a ranking as definitive. A champion with relatively few games from top players can get an unusually large gap just from noise.
The analysis described here adjusts each champion's gap toward its lane average, with smaller samples pulled further. That's a reasonable way to make thin samples less volatile, but the result still depends on that adjustment and the data period. The source excerpt doesn't include the actual rankings, so it doesn't establish which champions came out on top.
Reply to this answer
Mastery payoff and difficulty aren't interchangeable. A mechanically demanding champion might have a modest measured gap, while a less mechanically demanding one could show a bigger gap between specialists and average players. The statistic describes performance differences, not why they happen.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
buffSlot_17:
That gap isn't necessarily all caused by champion mastery, though. The groups being compared can differ in other ways too.