Which bruisers actually want Shojin over Black Cleaver? Hecarim is the main example I can think of, and with Cleaver getting buffed, I'm not sure when Shojin is the better choice.
When would a bruiser buy Shojin instead of Black Cleaver?
Answers
The matchup matters as much as the champion. Black Cleaver becomes more attractive when the enemy team has armor you can shred and physical damage teammates who can benefit from it. Shojin has to offer enough for your own spell rotation to make up for giving that up.
I'd compare the current item stats and effects on the patch you're playing, then think about whether the fight is mostly about getting more casts off or dealing with armored targets. It's not necessarily the same answer every game.
Reply to this answer
Hecarim is at least one bruiser associated with Shojin, but I wouldn't use that alone to decide what to buy on someone else. Look at how reliably the champion can use its effects and whether the rest of the build already covers what Cleaver would provide.
A Cleaver buff could change the comparison, but the size of the buff matters. Without the actual patch numbers, it's hard to say Shojin will stop being worth buying.
Reply to this answer
They don't always have to compete for one slot. If both items work with your champion and the game goes long enough, you can consider buying both. The more useful question might be which one helps you sooner against the team you're facing.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
GBAmapper_6Z:
That makes sense. So Cleaver's value isn't just about how much armor my own champion needs to get through.