If a character fails a check to identify animal tracks, would you say they don't know what made them, or tell them they think the tracks belong to the wrong animal? How do you handle checks like this?
When a player fails a knowledge check, do you give them wrong information?
Answers
I'd usually just say they can't identify the tracks. A failed roll doesn't have to mean the character confidently believes something false. Sometimes they just don't have enough experience or the tracks aren't clear enough.
Reply to this answer
Wrong information can be fun, but I'd make sure the group is comfortable with it. If players know a low roll might produce a false answer, they can decide how much confidence to put in what their characters think they know.
For tracks, you could say they resemble a bear's, rather than declaring that a bear definitely made them. That leaves room for doubt without turning every failed check into a dead end.
Reply to this answer
I'd consider rolling in secret if the group likes uncertainty. Then a confident answer doesn't automatically reveal whether the check succeeded. Agree on that approach beforehand, though, since some players prefer seeing their own rolls.
scrimSub!NoWarmup:
That makes sense. A visible low roll would make it harder for the player not to doubt the answer.
Reply to this answer
Failure can still give the players something useful without identifying the animal. Maybe they can tell the tracks are fresh, or that several creatures passed through, but not what species made them. Then they have a clue and a reason to investigate further.
I wouldn't require a roll for information the characters need just to keep the game moving. Save the check for extra detail or an uncertain interpretation.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
GGsProbably:
That distinction helps. A tentative guess feels different from telling the player their character is certain.