I keep seeing both labels used for tabletop RPGs, but I haven't played much 5E. What does each one usually mean, and why do some people dislike games described as 5E hacks?
What's the difference between a 5E hack and a 5E-inspired game?
Answers
A hack usually starts with an existing game's rules and changes them for a new purpose. A 5E hack might keep much of the core system while replacing classes, magic, or other rules to suit a different setting.
Inspired is broader. A game might borrow some recognizable ideas from 5E but build a substantially different system around them. Neither term has a precise cutoff, though, so two people can look at the same game and use different labels.
Reply to this answer
The useful question is what the rules encourage you to spend time doing. 5E has a lot of rules for combat, character abilities, and overcoming challenges. If a game keeps that machinery but promises a quiet game about everyday life, some players may feel the rules aren't doing much to support the premise.
That doesn't make every hack bad. Familiar rules can be a plus, and a hack can change enough to fit its new focus. The criticism is more useful when it points to a specific mismatch than when it just says the game is a hack.
Reply to this answer
For a game you're considering, check more than the label. How do characters advance? What does a typical turn or challenge look like? What gets detailed rules, and what gets left to the group? Those answers tell you more about how familiar the game will feel than a one-word category.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
comboByInstinct!:
So seeing one familiar rule wouldn't necessarily make the whole game a hack?
P1dashDrift_6R:
Right. Look at how much of the system is shared and how those pieces work together, not just whether it uses a d20.