What would make a Dota 2 drafting roguelite fun to replay?

November 17, 2026 4 answers
Asked by ParryClerk!

A Dota 2 drafting game could have players pick a team one slot at a time, with bonuses for familiar player and hero pairings and for players who have competed together. What would make that system interesting beyond picking the strongest synergies?

Answers

rankedWithSnacks

Make synergy a tradeoff, not just a bigger number. A player might be very familiar with one hero, but picking it could leave the team without a reliable way to start fights or deal enough damage.

That gives each pick two jobs: improve the player pairing and fit the team being built. If the best familiarity bonus always wins, the draft could start solving itself.

Reply to this answer
dashCancelByKayak

I'd put some constraints on each run. Maybe the available players and heroes come from a limited pack, or a round asks for a particular team composition. Different pools would force new combinations instead of letting everyone chase the same lineup.

Those constraints should be visible before the draft starts, though. Otherwise a pick can feel bad because of information the player never had.

P2+SnackBreak:

A preview of the next challenge could work too. Enough information to plan, but not necessarily the whole run.

Reply to this answer
DLCroute!Mothball

The scoring needs to explain itself. Show the player and hero familiarity bonus, the shared professional experience bonus, and how much each contributes. Raw game counts alone could also favor players with longer careers, so some normalization might be worth testing.

If historical tournament packs are the source of the pool, show which event a pack represents. That makes the selection easier to understand without pretending the numbers capture every aspect of a player's skill.

Reply to this answer
rankedOnBicycle

Give the team something to face after drafting. An opponent draft or a series of matchups could reward different strengths, so a lineup that's great in one round isn't automatically great in every round.

It doesn't need a full Dota simulation to start. A transparent matchup score could be enough to test whether the draft decisions are fun.

ParryClerk!:

A simpler matchup score sounds like a useful starting point. The tricky part would be making its reasons clear to the player.

Reply to this answer

Add your answer

Answers are reviewed before publication.

Related Discussions