I like the character options and tactical choices in 5e combat, but turns can drag. What other systems keep combat detailed and character-driven while resolving it faster? I'm not looking for combat to be reduced to a mostly cinematic scene.
What turn-based RPG combat stays tactical without taking forever?
Answers
Shadow of the Demon Lord is worth a look if you want to stay in fantasy territory. It keeps distinct character paths, positioning, spells, and meaningful combat choices, but uses boons and banes instead of stacking lots of modifiers.
Its fast and slow turn structure also cuts down on individual initiative bookkeeping. The tradeoff is that it's a pretty grim game by default, so the tone may not be what you want.
Reply to this answer
I'd check out 13th Age. It has recognizable fantasy classes and plenty of combat abilities, but handles distance more loosely than a square-by-square grid. Mooks can also make groups of minor enemies easier to run.
The escalation die encourages fights to move toward a conclusion. That said, if precise positioning is the tactical part you enjoy most, the abstract distances might feel like a loss rather than an improvement.
Reply to this answer
For something less like 5e, Savage Worlds has tactical combat with movement, positioning, powers, and character edges. Extras are simpler to take out than major characters, which can help when there are lots of opponents.
It does use cards for initiative and has its own conditions and combat options to learn. Fast isn't guaranteed just because the dice work differently, especially while everyone is learning the rules.
Reply to this answer
Dragonbane might fit if you want a lighter fantasy system without giving up combat decisions. It uses a roll-under d20, has tactical movement and conditions, and makes dodging or parrying cost your action for the round. That's a meaningful choice without a lot of modifier math.
Characters won't necessarily have the same breadth of class features as 5e characters, though. I'd look at the character options as well as the combat rules before switching.
Reply to this answer
I'd separate fast turns from fast fights when comparing games. Fewer modifiers can make a roll quicker, but a fight can still drag if everyone has lots of abilities to scan or enemies take many hits to drop.
Try the same sort of encounter in a couple of candidates and check how much time goes into choosing actions, resolving attacks, and tracking damage and conditions. A game with fewer character options might be faster but miss the part of 5e you're trying to keep.
Reply to this answer
Add your answer
Answers are reviewed before publication.
scrimFillByCorkscrew:
Shadow of the Weird Wizard uses related ideas with a different fantasy tone, so that may be worth comparing too.